Guides / Integrals
Arc length and surface area: √(1 + (y′)²) under the integral, and 2πr for the surface
Short answer
For y = f(x) on [a, b], the arc length is L = ∫ab √(1 + (y′)2) dx. Square the derivative, add 1, and look for a perfect square under the root; never split √(1 + (y′)2) into 1 + y′. Turning the curve about an axis gives a surface of area S = ∫ 2πr ds, where ds = √(1 + (y′)2) dx is the slant width of each band and r is the distance to the axis of turning: r = y about the x-axis, r = x about the y-axis.
Why it works
Over a short step dx the curve rises about dy = y′ dx, so the piece of curve is close to the hypotenuse of a right triangle with legs dx and dy. Its length is ds = √(dx2 + dy2) = √(1 + (y′)2) dx, and adding the pieces is integrating. That's also the quickest check: an arc is never shorter than the straight chord between its ends, and never longer than the path along the axes.
When the piece of length ds is turned about an axis, it sweeps out a band shaped like a slice of a cone. Cut open and laid flat, the band is nearly a strip of length 2πr and width ds, not dx: the band runs along the slanted curve. Where the curve is flat the two are close, and where it is steep ds is much bigger.
Example 1: a substitution under the root
Find the length of y = 23x3/2 from x = 0 to x = 8.
- y′ = x1/2, 1 + (y′)2 = 1 + xSquare the derivative before adding 1.
- L = ∫08 (1 + x)1/2 dxThe arc-length integral.
- = 23[(1 + x)3/2]08The power rule, with u = 1 + x.
- L = 23(27 − 1) = 523 ≈ 17.33Check: the curve ends at (8, 15.08), and the chord from (0, 0) has length 17.07, a little shorter.
Example 2: a perfect square under the root
Find the length of y = x48 + 14x2 from x = 1 to x = 2.
- y′ = x32 − 12x3Differentiate term by term.
- 1 + (y′)2 = x64 + 12 + 14x6The middle term of (y′)² is −1/2, and adding 1 flips its sign.
- = (x32 + 12x3)2A perfect square. Curves like this are built so that it happens.
- L = ∫12 (x32 + 12x3) dxThe square root is gone.
- = [x48 − 14x2]12Integrate each term.
- L = (2 − 116) − (18 − 14)Upper limit minus lower limit.
- = 3316 = 2.0625Check: the chord from (1, 3/8) to (2, 33/16) has length about 1.96.
Example 3: a trig identity under the root
Find the length of y = ln(cos x) from x = 0 to x = π4.
- y′ = −sin xcos x = −tan xThe chain rule on ln.
- 1 + tan2 x = sec2 xThe Pythagorean identity.
- √(1 + (y′)2) = sec xsec x > 0 on this interval, so no absolute value is needed.
- L = ∫0π/4 sec x dxThe arc-length integral.
- = ln(sec x + tan x)|0π/4The standard antiderivative of sec x.
- = ln(√2 + 1) ≈ 0.8814At 0, ln(1 + 0) = 0. Check: the chord to (π/4, ln(√2/2)) has length about 0.858.
Example 4: a surface about the x-axis
Find the area of the surface made by turning y = x3, 0 ≤ x ≤ 1, about the x-axis.
- r = y = x3, ds = √(1 + 9x4) dxAbout the x-axis the radius is the height of the curve; y′ = 3x².
- S = ∫01 2πx3√(1 + 9x4) dxCircumference times slant width.
- u = 1 + 9x4, du = 36x3 dxThe x³ from the radius is exactly what the substitution needs.
- S = 2π36∫110 u1/2 duThe limits change to u = 1 and u = 10.
- S = π18 · 23(103/2 − 1)The power rule on u1/2.
- = π27(10√10 − 1) ≈ 3.563Units of length squared, as an area should have.
Example 5: a cone about the y-axis, checked by geometry
Turn the segment y = 2x, 0 ≤ x ≤ 1, about the y-axis, and find the area of the cone it makes.
- r = xAbout the y-axis the radius is horizontal, the distance x.
- ds = √(1 + 22) dx = √5 dxThe slope is 2.
- S = ∫01 2πx√5 dx = π√5The integral of 2x from 0 to 1 is 1.
- S = π√5 ≈ 7.025Check with the cone formula πrℓ: the base radius is 1 and the slant height is √(1² + 2²) = √5.
Common mistakes, and the exact line they happen on
1. Taking the square root term by term
The curve from Example 1.
- 1 + (y′)2 = 1 + xRight so far.
- √(1 + x) = 1 + √xThis is the mistake. It leads to L = ∫08 (1 + √x) dx ≈ 23.08. √(a + b) is not √a + √b: squaring 1 + √x gives 1 + 2√x + x. The 23.08 is 8 + 15.08, exactly the path along the axes, which an arc can never exceed. The length is 52/3 ≈ 17.33.
2. Leaving out the slant factor
The surface from Example 4.
- r = x3Right so far.
- S = ∫01 2πx3 dx = π2 ≈ 1.571This is the mistake. The band's width was taken as dx, as in a volume by shells. Along the surface the band is ds = √(1 + 9x⁴) dx wide, which near x = 1 is more than three times dx. With it, S ≈ 3.563.
3. Measuring the radius from the wrong axis
The cone from Example 5.
- ds = √5 dxRight so far.
- S = ∫01 2πy dsThis is the mistake. It gives ∫01 2π(2x)√5 dx = 2π√5 ≈ 14.05. y is the distance to the x-axis, so this is the area of a different cone, the one made by turning the segment about the x-axis, with base radius 2. About the y-axis, each point travels on a circle of radius x, and S = π√5 ≈ 7.025.
Practice
Find the length of y = 3x − 2 from x = 1 to x = 4, and check it with the distance formula.
Show answer
√(1 + 9) = √10, so L = 3√10 ≈ 9.487. The ends are (1, 1) and (4, 10), at distance √(9 + 81) = 3√10.
Find the length of y = 13(x2 + 2)3/2 from x = 0 to x = 1.
Show answer
y′ = x√(x2 + 2), so 1 + (y′)2 = x4 + 2x2 + 1 = (x2 + 1)2, and L = ∫01 (x2 + 1) dx = 43.
Find the length of y = x22 − ln x4 from x = 1 to x = e.
Show answer
y′ = x − 14x, and 1 + (y′)2 = (x + 14x)2. So L = [x22 + ln x4]1e = 2e2 − 14 ≈ 3.445.
Turn y = √(4 − x2), −1 ≤ x ≤ 1, about the x-axis. Find the area of this band of a sphere.
Show answer
ds = 2√(4 − x2) dx, so 2πy ds = 4π dx and S = 4π · 2 = 8π ≈ 25.13.
Turn y = 2√x, 0 ≤ x ≤ 3, about the x-axis, and find the surface area.
Show answer
y′ = 1√x, so 2πy√(1 + (y′)2) = 4π√x · √(x + 1x) = 4π√(x + 1), and S = 4π · 23(8 − 1) = 56π3 ≈ 58.64.